Over the years many Comets players have been able to pursue their baseball or softball beyond the Club. This is in line with our Mission and we’re proud of these players, their performance and achievements.
Note: This list is not complete and is a work in progress. If you’re aware of a player’s achievement that isn’t recorded here, please let us know.
| 2023 | |
| Australian Women's Team | Ticara Geldenhuis |
| 2023 STGBA | |
| 4th Grade Grand Final MVP Trevor Geldenhuis | |
| 2022-2023 CSJBA | |
| CSJBA - Little League Minors Rep Cooper Jacenko, Lincoln Potter and Kai Shibata | CSJBA Little League Majors Rep Zac Jacenko |
| CSJBA - Junior League Rep Jake Bolling | |
| 2022-2023 CSMLBA | |
| 1st Grade Grand Final MVP Brett Elliott | |
| 2020-21 CSJBA | |
| Senior League 2 Grand Final MVP Toby McDonald | Little League Minor 2 Grand Final MVP Keiran Brain |
| 2019-20 CSJBA | |
| CSJBA – 2020 Little League Minors Team Simon Pillington | CSJBA – 2020 Junior League Squad Reilly Vanzantan |
| 2019 STGBA | |
| 4th Grade Grand Final MVP Ryan Smith | |
| 2nd Grade MVP The "Orioles" Trophy Andrew Staniforth | 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Michael Everett |
| 2018-19 CSJBA | |
| CSJBA – Little League (BALFOUR CUP TEAM) Kuean Geldenhuis | CSJBA – Junior League (STATE CUP TEAM) Reilly Vanzantan |
| 2018-19 CSMLBA | |
| 1st Grade Grand Final MVP Brett Elliott | |
| 2018 STGBA | |
| 8th Grade MVP The "Norm Hord" Trophy Paul Scott | |
| 2015-16 CSJBA | |
| NSW Metro U16’s Women’s team Ticara Geldenhuis | NSW Country U16’s Women’s team Kirsty Packer Jasmin Garrison |
| Cronulla Junior Team Joshua Bishopp | Cronulla Rookie West Team Kuean Geldenhuis Blake Kendrick Reilly Vanzanten Luke Proudlock Kale Hadenham |
| 2015-16 CSMLBA | |
| 2nd Grade Grand Final MVP Dane Brooking | |
| 2015 STGBA | |
| 3rd Grade Grand Final MVP Harrison Riley | 4th Grade Grand Final MVP Jason Noye |
| 8th Grade Grand Final MVP Bradley Teasel | |
| 2014-15 CSJBA | |
| U14/2’s MVP Hayley Claringbold | NSW U15’s Youth Women’s Winning team Ticara Geldenhuis |
| NSW Country U15’s Youth Women’s Team Kirsty Packer Jasmin Garrison | Rookie West Team Kuean Geldenhuis Toby McDonald Blake Kendrick Reilly Vanzanten |
| 2013-14 | |
| Australian 18 Under team James Philibossian | NSW 16 Under team James Wayland |
| NSW Women’s Blue Sox team Lauren McGrath | NSW Women’s 18 Under team Lauren Donellan |
| 2013 STGBA | |
| 1st Grade Grand Final MVP Craig Bunker (Gump) | |
| 2012-13 | |
| National Women’s team Lauren McGrath | NSW U17 School Sport Australia team Lachlan Wayland |
| International Activity James Philibossian signed with Detriot Tigers | NSW Women’s team Renae Ackling Lauren McGrath |
| Under 15 CJSBA Girls Representative team (JAG) Alysia Cavanagh Tahlia Claringbold Erin Lamberton | Under 13 CJSBA Girls Representative team (JAG) Hayley Claringbold Ticara Geldenhuis Kaewta Nusuwan Amy Rose |
| NSW Under 18 State Team James Philibossian Lachlan Wayland | NSW Under 16 State Team Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin |
| Under 16 “AA” State Cup Brandon Foster Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin James Wayland | Under 16 “AA” State Cup All Stars Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin |
| 2012 | |
| National Women’s team Lauren McGrath | NSW CHS – Softball team Renae Ackling |
| NSW U17 Girls Friendship team Kirsten Eden | NSW Country U15 Girls Friendship team Tahlia Claringbold Erin Lamberton |
| NSWWBL “A” Grade MVP NSWWBL “A” Grade Pitcher Lauren McGrath | World Boys Tournament Squad Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin |
| 2012 STGBA | |
| 1st Grade Grand Final MVP Craig Bunker (Gump) | |
| 2011-12 CSMLBA | |
| 1st Div Grand Final MVP xx | 7th Div Grand Final MVP xx |
| 2011-12 Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 National Youth Championship team James Philibossian | Under 16 “AA” State Cup Championship Bailey Musulin James Philibossian |
| Under 16 Development Cup Brandon Foster | NSW Under 14 National Youth Championship team James Wayland |
| Under 14 “A” State Cup Calum Gorman James Wayland | Under 13 CJSBA Girls Representative team (JAG) Tahlia Claringbold Ticara Geldenhuis Erin Lamberton |
| Little League South Calum Gormam | Rookie Cup South Roy Munro |
| 2011 STGBA | |
| 8th Grade MVP (Norm Hord Award) Joe Potter | |
| STGBA Strike Outs (K2) Award The "George Boyce" Trophy David Daniels (52 K2's) | |
| 4th Grade MVP The "Dennis Mannix" Trophy Trevor Geldenhuis | |
| 2011 | |
| Australian Women’s National Squad NSW Lauren McGrath | National Women’s team Lauren McGrath |
| NSW U17 Girls Friendship team Renee Ackling Koby Maber | NSW U15 Girls Friendship team Kirsten Eden |
| 2010-11 Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 National Youth Championship James Philibossian | NSW Under 14 National Youth Championship Bailey Musulin |
| Under 16 “AA” State Cup Championship Craig Elliott James Philibossian | Under 16 “AA” Development team Zac Jones Lachlan Wayland |
| Under 16 NSW “AA” Junior League All Stars team Craig Elliott | Under 14 NSW “A” Junior League All Stars team Bailey Musulin |
| Under 14 “A” State Cup Championship Brandon Foster Calum Gorman Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin | Under 14 “A” Development team James Wayland |
| Under 15 CSJBA Girls Representative team (JAG) Kirsten Eden Sophie McLaren | Under 13 CJSBA Girls Representative team (JAG) Hayley Claringbold Tahlia Claringbold Emma Gidney Erin Lamberton |
| Sydney East PSSA – Softball James Wayland | NSW Team PSSA – Softball James Wayland |
| 2010 STGBA | |
| 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Sean Leong | |
| 8th Grade MVP The "Norm Hord" Trophy Noel Bowman | |
| 2009-10 Rep players | |
| Australian Women’s National Sqaud Lauren McGrath | NSW National Women’s Championship Lauren McGrath |
| Under 16 “AA” Sydney Junior Championship Ryan Gannon Zac Jones | Under 16 “AA” Development Cup Craig Elliot Coen Simmons-Smith Blake Sykes Lachlan Wayland |
| Under 16 All Girls Development League Sydney Junior Championship Kirsten Eden | NSW Under 14 National Youth Championship James Philibossian (Captain) |
| Under 14 “A” Sydney Junior Championship Brandon Foster Connor Gorman James Philibossian | Under 14 “A” Development Cup Bailey Musulin |
| Under 13 All Girls Development League Sydney Junior Championship Erin Lamberton Hayley Claringbold (train-on/rotation) Emma Gidley (train-on/rotation) | Little League Sydney Junior Championship Calum Gorman James Wayland |
| NSW Girls Little League v Queensland team Renee Addicoat Kirsten Eden Alannah Noye | NSW Girls Little League team Renee Addicoat Kirsten Eden Alannah Noye |
| 2009 STGBA | |
| 2nd Grade MVP The "Orioles" Trophy Andrew Staniforth | 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Cameron Hall |
| 6th Grade MVP The "Dennis Johnson" Memorial Trophy Pat Waaka | 8th Grade MVP The "Norm Hord Trophy" Troy Pirschel |
| STGBA Most Strike Outs (K2) Award The "George Boyce" Trophy Troy Pirschel (51 K2's) | |
| 2008-09 Rep players | |
| International Activity David Kandilas signed with Colorado Rockies | Australian Under 19 team (AAA’s) David Kandilas |
| NSW Girls U16 Koby Maber | Under 16 Sydney Championship Michael Philibossian |
| Under 14 NSW Development Squad Zac Jones James Philibossian | Sydney East PSSA – Softball Renee Addicoat Kirsten Eden |
| Under 14 Association Cup Craig Elliott Blake Sykes | Under 14 Sydney Championship Craig Elliott Zac Jones James Philibossian Lachlan Wayland |
| Under 12 Sydney Championship Brandon Foster Calum Gorman Connor Gorman Bailey Musulin | Little League Autumn Classic Lachlan Wayland James Philibossian |
| Under 12 Association Cup James Wayland | |
| 2008 STGBA | |
| 5th Grade Grand Final MVP Sean Leong | 7th Grade Grand Final MVP Robin Andrews |
| 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Andrew Devlin | 5th Grade MVP The "Miall Smith" Trophy Jason Noye |
| STGBA Most Strike Outs (K2) Award The "George Boyce" Trophy Jason Noye (79 K2's) | |
| 2007-08 Rep players | |
| Under 16 Association Cup Ben King Michael Philibossian | Under 14 Sydney Championship Ryan Gannon Lachlan Wayland |
| Under 14 Association Cup Craig Elliott Zac Jones James Rowan Coen Simmons-Smith | Under 14 NSW Development Squad Zac Jones |
| Under 12 Sydney Championship Connor Gorman James Philibossian | Under 12 Association Cup Mitchell Gannon Bailey Musulin |
| Under 12 NSW Development Squad Connor Gorman James Philibossian | NSW Autumn Classic Tournament held in Auckland, New Zealand Coen Simmons-Smith |
| Oregon Scientific Phoenix Cup – Aussie Hearts Koby Maber | Sydney East PSSA – Softball Lachlan Wayland |
| 2006-07 Rep players | |
| AA (Under 17) Australian side Alex Howe | NSW State Women’s Lauren McGrath |
| NSW Under 18 State Side Ryan Griffin David Kandilas | NSW Women’s U14 touring team Koby Maber |
| NSW Under 16 State Side Alex Howe | Under 16 Sydney Championship Dylan Arnold Dean Braidotti Brett Elliott Alex Howe |
| Under 16 Association Cup Ben King | Under 14 Association Cup Ryan Gannon Jacob Lockwood Coen Simmons-Smith |
| Under 12 Sydney Championship Craig Elliott Zac Jones Lachlan Wayland | Under 12 Association Cup James Philibossian |
| 2005-06 Rep players | |
| NSW State Women’s Lauren McGrath | NSW Under 16 State Side David Kandilas |
| NSW Country Under 16 Doug Ineson | Under 16 Sydney Championship Andrew Callaghan Craig Harris Alexander Howe David Kandilas |
| Under 14 Association Cup Zac Howe Benjamin King | Under 12 Sydney Championship Ryan Gannon Coen Simmons-Smith |
| Under 12 Association Cup Zac Jones Daniel King Jacob Lockwood | |
| 2004-05 Rep players | |
| NSW Women’s Baseball State Side Lauren McGrath | NSW Under 16 State Side Youth League Ryan Griffin Andrew Callaghan Ryan Griffin David Kandilas |
| Under 16 Association Cup Under 12 Association Cup Matthew Boseley Anthony Grigg Craig Harris Adam Smith Matthew Steadman Daniel King Jacob Lockwood Anthony Sawdy | |
| 2004 STGBA | |
| 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Clinton Foster | |
| 2003-04 Rep players | |
| Youth League Under 16 Development Squad Ryan Griffin Matthew Boseley Anthony Grigg David Grigg Adam Smith | Under 14 State Cup Carl Ripken 2003 Tour Andrew Callaghan Craig Harris David Kandilas Matthew Steadman Andrew Callaghan David Kandilas |
| 2004 STGBA | |
| 7th Grade MVP The "Chris Appel" Memorial Trophy Greg Phair | 7th Grade Grand Final MVP Peter Mitchell |
| 2002-03 CSJBA Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 State Side NSW Under 14 State Side Bradley Callaghan Ryan Griffin | Youth League Under 16 Development Squad Bradley Callaghan Nathan Hollett Jesse Keller Greg Robinson |
| Under 14 State Cup Under 14 Development Squad Andrew Callaghan Ryan Griffin Matthew Boseley Matthew Steadman | |
| 2002 STGBA | |
| 5th Grade Grand Final MVP David Jackson | |
| 2001-02 CSJBA Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 State Side Youth League Shaun Lindsay Bradley Callaghan Ben Evans Andrew Hodges Nathan Hollett | Under 16 Development Squad Under 14 Development Squad Greg Robinson Nathan Smith Matthew Boseley Ryan Griffin Anthony Grigg David Grigg Philip Ramsay Adam Smith |
| Under 12 State Cup Under 12 Development Squad Andrew Callaghan Matthew Steadman Dane Fazakerley | |
| 2001 STGBA | |
| 8th Grade MVP The "Norm Hord" Trophy Glenn Ollerton | 8th Grade MVP Greg Phair |
| 9th Grade John Baker Trophy | 8th Grade Grand Final MVP Scott Tully |
| STGBA Most Home Runs The "Ken Howard" Trophy Greg Phair | |
| 2000-01 CSJBA Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 State Side NSW Under 14 State Side Matthew Callaghan Brad Callaghan Nathan Hollett | Youth League Under 16 Development Squad Matthew Callaghan Shaun Lindsay Ben Evans Nathan Smith |
| Under 14 State Cup Under 14 Development Squad Brad Callaghan Andrew Hodges Nathan Hollett Jesse Keller Tom Keller Travis Mitchell Greg Robinson Dale Stewart | Under 12 State Cup Under 12 Development Squad Andrew Callaghan John Logue Phillip Ramsay Mathew Boseley Ryan Griffin Adam Smith Matthew Steadman |
| 2000 STGBA | |
| 2nd Grade MVP The "Orioles" Trophy David Daniels | 7th Grade MVP The "Chris Appel" Memorial Trophy Phil Trevenar |
| STGBA Most Strike Outs (K2) Award The "George Boyce" Trophy Phil Trevenar | |
| 1999-2000 CSJBA Rep players | |
| Youth League NSW Under 14 State Side Matthew Callaghan Shaun Lindsay | Under 14 State Cup Under 14 Development Squad Brad Callaghan Nathan Hollett Ben Evans Nathan Smith |
| Under 12 State Cup Under 12 Development Squad Dale Stewart Philip Ramsay | |
| 1999 STGBA | |
| 3rd Grade MVP The " Jim Strickland" Trophy Jason Noye | 5th Grade MVP The "Mail Smith" Trophy Andrew Staniforth |
| 1998 STGBA | |
| 1st Grade MVP Anthony Moir | 1st Grade Ray Lawler Trophy |
| 5th Grade MVP Andrew Staniforth | 5th Grade Mail Smith Trophy |
| 1998 Juniors | |
| Under 14 MVP James “Tails” Taylor | Under 14 Batting Average Jason Boseley (.583) |
| Under 16 MVP Clinton Foster | Under 16 Batting Average Michael Turner (.730) |
| 1998 Seniors | |
| 1st Grade MVP David Westall | 1st Grade Batting Average Anthony Moir (.478) |
| 2nd Grade MVP Dean Whitlock | 2nd Grade Batting Average Dean Whitlock (.667) |
| 3rd Grade MVP Chris Crowe | 3rd Grade Batting Average Stewart Martin (.621) |
| 5th Grade MVP Peter Cooper | 5th Grade Batting Average Mike Cafe (.485) |
| 8th Grade MVP Jason Noye | 8th Grade Batting Average Scott Tully (.648) |
| 9th Grade MVP Gary Parker | 9th Grade Batting Average Mark Eades (.813) |
| 1997 STBA | |
| 3rd Grade MVP The "Jim Strickland" Trophy Matthew Talbot | 7th Grade MVP The "Chris Appel" Memorial Trophy Phil Trevenar |
| 1997 Juniors | |
| Under 16AA IBA World Cup Brett Murray Adam Murphy | |
| 1996 STGBA | |
| 2nd Grade MVP The "Orioles" Trophy Scott Burgess | 6th Grade MVP The "Dennis Johnson" Trophy Phil Trevenar |
| 1995-96 Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 State Cup Brett Murray Adam Murphy Philip Cooper Nathan Cullen | State Cup Under 16 Adam Murphy Brett Murray Ryan Wailes |
| State Cup Under 14 Development Squad Carl McElroy Chris Hollett | PSSA Met East Softball Chad Ashton |
| Under 14 Jeffrey Arthur Martin McDonald Darren Mullard Darren Sanchez | |
| 1994-95 Rep players | |
| NSW Open Womens Softball NSW Under 19 Softball Melinda Wright Gretchen Ryan Sheridan Ryan Shenelle Whetu Natalie Wood | CS Rep Baseball Under 16 & State Cup Under 14 Baseball Wade Ball Brett Murray |
| Under 14 Invitational District Baseball Dev. Met East Secondary Softball Nathan Mackie Adam Proudlock Anthony Lax Wade Ball Carl McElroy | Met East Primary Softball CS Rep Under 14 Softball Carl McElroy John Phizacklea |
| CS Rep Under 12 Baseball Chad Ashton | |
| 1991-92 Rep players | |
| CS District Baseball Under 18 Indians Touring Team Stephen Bourke Glen McDonald Mathew Gibson Martin Spencer Craig Hemphill Joshua Kellett | State Cup Under 16 Baseball & State Cup Under 16 Softball Brett Griffiths Chris Weaver Joel Morgan Joshua Kellett Mathew Schumacher Craig Hemphill Jeffrey Mead Katherine Dunn Gretchen Ryan Shenelle Whetu Natalie Wood Melinda Wright |
| State Cup Under 12 Baseball State Cup & Under 14 Baseball Owen Sharpe Mathew Wright Andrew Meagher | Met East Primary Softball Wade Ball Kimberley Booth Lauren Heard Elise Jones Anthony Lax Daneil Richmond Kim Rogers Paul Voges Megan Williams Mathew Wright |
| 1990-91 Rep players | |
| NSW Metropolitan Team Martin Spencer Justin Taylor Martin McDonald | Under 16 Indians Touring Team Justin Taylor |
| CS State Cup Under 16 Baseball CS State Cup Under 14 Baseball Steve Bourke Scott Burgess Matthew Gibson Glen McDonald Martin Spencer Justin Taylor Greg Bourke Craig Hemphill Jeff Mead Matthew Schumacher Michael Street | NSW Under 16 at National Championship - Softball Melinda Wright Renee Jones Kylie Mellords Gretchen Ryan Sheridan Ryan |
| Under 16 Sutherland Rep - Softball Melinda Wright | Under 14 Sutherland Rep Softball & Under 12 Sutherland Rep Softball Jodie Matheson Elise Jones Sarah Meagher Kimberley Booth Katie Morgan |
| CS State Cup Under 12 - Baseball Wade Ball Matthew Hutchinson Clint Butcher Lachlan Kalif Anthony Lax Tim Wallace | |
| 1989-90 Rep players | |
| NSW Under 16 Rep – Baseball Justin Taylor Blair Delzoppo | Under 16 Indians Team – Baseball Justin Taylor Blair Delzoppo Glen McDonald |
| Under 15 Rep – Softball & Under 13 Rep – Softball Kylie Wardrobe Gretchen Ryan Sheridan Ryan Karyn Aldous Renee Jones Kylie Mellords Melinda Wright | Under 14 State Cup – Baseball & Under 12 State Cup – Baseball Greg Bourke Brett Griffiths Craig Hemphill Joel Morgan Matthew Schumacher Mike Street Brad Taylor Melinda Wright Peter Barry Cameron Booth Brett Cooper Ryan Delzoppo Lucian Hiss Brett Lloyd Andrew Meagher |
| Under 12 Rep – Softball & Under 11 Rep – Softball Jodi Matheson Lauren Heard Elise Jones Kim Miller Kimberly Booth Megan Williams Sarah Meagher | Met East PSSA – Softball Met East CHS – Softball Steven Angus Cameron Booth Craig Hemphill Jeff Mead Melinda Wright |
| 1988-89 Rep players | |
| Under 16 Association Cup & Under 16 Indians Touring Team Blair Delzoppo Ben Clay Blair Delzoppo Justin Taylor | Under 14 NSW Interstate Challenge Series & Under 14 NSW State Team Glen McDonald Justin Taylor |
| Under 14 Association Cup & Under 12 Association Cup Glen McDonald Justin Taylor Craig Hemphill Jeff Mead Matthew Schumacher Mike Street Brad Taylor Melinda Wright | Under 13 Softball & Under 12 Softball Renelle Heard Samantha McKinnon Kelly Miller Renee Jones Kylie Mellords Melinda Wright |
| 1987 STGBA | |
| 6-7th Grade MVP Craig Lincoln | 6-7th Grade Dennis Johnson Memorial Trophy |
| 1984-85 Rep players | |
| Under 17 Jeffrey Arthur | Under 15 Jeffrey Arthur Mark Gear Darren Harrower Martin McDonald Darren Mullard Stuart Raymond Darren Sanchez |
| Under 12 & Under 11 Ben Clay Shane Gear Bradley Harrower Reece Hooke Brad Fox Daniel Wallace | |
| 1983-84 Rep players | |
| Under 15 Jeffrey Arthur Martin McDonald Darren Sanchez | Under 14 Jeffrey Arthur Darren Harrower Martin McDonald Darren Mullard Darren Sanchez Stuart Zadel |
| Under 12 Shane Morton Reece Hooke Ben Clay | Under 11 Ben Clay Shane Gear Bradley Harrower |
| Under 9 David Daniels Glen McDonald Craig Pollard Jonathon Smythe | |
| 1982-93 Rep players | |
